Ife’s prosperity attracted newcomers. Individuals and families were absorbed into existing lineages, but whole groups looking for land were not, and the old settlements guarded their farm boundaries jealously. A “strangers’ area” grew up, and one of its groups, led in the later stages by a man called Oduduwa, refused to accept the older settlements’ claim to precedence.
The traditions describe decades of fighting, though they differ in detail. A leader called Oreluere defeated Oduduwa’s people and imposed a tribute, but they recovered; some old settlements joined Oduduwa; others were destroyed. Obatala, king of Ideta and chairman of the alliance, led the resistance but lost followers because of his erratic behaviour. He was driven out to a camp called Ideta-Oko, where smallpox weakened his followers. A prince named Ojumu then brokered a peace: Obatala’s people returned to Ife and Oduduwa became the dominant ruler. A hard core of refusers settled at Igbo-Igbo and raided the new city for years.
The scholar Akin Ogundiran suggests that the troubles lasted from the late 9th to the early 11th century. Oduduwa and Obatala were the leading figures at the end, not necessarily at the beginning, and Akintoye reasons that the group called “Oduduwa’s” probably arrived under his parents or grandparents. Memory of the conflict is still performed every year in the Ife festival of Itapa: priests of Obatala mark their bodies with white dots recalling the smallpox, the people mourn the expulsion, and on the eleventh day they celebrate the peace and the return of Obatala.
One famous story belongs to the Igbo-Igbo raids: the tale of Moremi, the wife of a king, who let herself be captured, learned the raiders’ secrets and helped end the attacks, at the price of sacrificing her only son to a river spirit. Akintoye notes that we do not know how much of the tale is history and how much is fiction, but that it expresses how deeply the people loved their new city.